Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salaam,

Dear brother khaledgr8,

you said that Hazrat Imam Hussain (rt) made a big mistake due to which many muslims were killed...... I am extremely sorry to say but WHO killed those many muslims ??? This is extremely strange approach that "the killer" ( whoever he is, either Yazeed or someone else ) is innocent and Imam Hussain (rt) is (Nauzbillah) culprit .....

According to this logic, what would you say about Hazrat Ali (rt) and Hazrat Ayesha (rt) ?

Hazrat Abdullah Ibne Abaas (rt) stopped Hazrat Hussain (rt) simply because he knew these people of Kufa..... Hazrat Imam Hussain (rt) was not accompanied by the other Sahaba (rt) simply because Hazrat Imam Hussain (rt) was not going for any battle, if it was the plan then the Sahaba (rt) must have accompanied him..... Its not necessary that everyone should go with you on every journey

Yazid was son of Hazrat Moawiya (rt), now what does that prove ??? Don't you remember the son of the Prophet Noah (ah)...... he was the son of the Prophet..... Yazid was the son of a companion only..... Hazrat Moawiya (rt) is not responsible of any act of the Yazid....

There was a forecaste of Eden for Yazeed..... please provide full reference.

You said, "Yazid had Just ordered Ibne Ziyad to take only BAITH"

Just for sometime, I agree with you..... Do you think it is right to gat BAITH with FORCE ?????

Then you gave a very interesting statement ,

"By your view it is mean now every muslim should be take a gun and go to america and killed Bush because we majority are against americans and it will be the step of genius"

Do you think that Hazrat Imam Hussain (rt) set out this journey to fight with Yazeed ????? This is an aboslutely childish approach, A person with 70 Men & Children and almost 12 ladies ( His own Family members, including a baby of few months ) is going to FIGHT against the Government....... I am extremely sorry to say but no sensible person would accept this

Do you really think that "Islam" spreads ..... brother it was only Government which spreads, not Islam....

In the end, brother what i see here is you are just playing with words and history, about which no one can be absolutely sure.

You haven't answered even a single question and keep on putting new questions in every post..... What you want to prove by this.....

If you think that we are on the wrong side then why don't you answer any question ?

I don't see any advantage of continuing this discussion as you are just keep on saying what you want to say and you never listen to anyother person, so This is end from me. May be someother member will be able to continue.

Edited by: atifrafi on Thursday, March 03, 2005 6:52 AM[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview