Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote][quote] I would also simply ask you perhaps to sit down and make a list of good v damage that has resulted to Islam as result of introduction of hadith & then perhaps you can tell us how valueable, you feel, hadith have been to Islam. [/quote]

Hadith is indeed an invaluable record about the last messenger of God.It is invaluable not just because of amount of time the scholars spent to record them,but because of their pain-staking effort to analyze,scrutinize the credibility of large number of narrators and their narrations of the Prophet,which makes it a credible record.In spite of this,I must agree with you that it cannot be a religious source of Islam.The blame for whatever "damage" that is caused after the recording of narrations should be placed on the muslim's attitude towards hadith , and not on the hadith itself.

[quote]  I glad to know that you do not consider hadith as religious source of Islam. Very good. At the same time you said that all the sources of religion are found in Quran and the Sunnah. But could you please tell me how can you know which one is Prophet's Sunnah or which one is not if you don't read hadith? Above all I ask you a question, is Sunnah a different source rather than the Nobel Qur'an? Has any reference in the Nobel Qur'an of 'Muhammad's Sunnah'? If your cherished Sunnah differ with the commandments of the Nobel Qur'an then what should you do? [/quote]

I repeat that you register for the course "Understanding the Sunnah",you will insha Allah find answers to all the above questions.All these questions are already discussed in the course forum.If you have further questions,please  post them in the course forum and you can discuss them there.

Regarding other questions you asked me,I suggest let us first resolve the question raised by Mr.Tariq first, before we move on to the next question.Further,I noticed throughout the forum that you usually jump from one question to another without even resolving the first one.Hence let us resolve his question first.

[quote] "On what basis did[ or should]the previous generations believed Quran to be the word of God,when the scientific information in it is unfolded during later times?". [/quote]

Edited by: amnew on Sunday, March 13, 2005 2:51 PM[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview