Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote][quote]Isnt dis debatable that through out our exsistence there is no proof that a woman as not lead da pray where both male n female r under da same masjid!So y now?[/quote]

Nobody ever used to put wheels on their bags, which make our lives easier...should we not put whells on our bags just because nobody did it before? What are we, sheep?

[quote]There r mny things that did not appen at that time so r u sayn dat its OK now 2 go ahead n do dem as its not haram or halal?[/quote]

Haram and Hallal follows more logic than it does repitition.  Haram is something which causes harm, and hallal is something which causes good.

Can you logically convince any normal human being that a woman leading prayer will cause any harm?

[quote]The argumnt is not bout Haram or Halal, its bout wot v shuld b folowing n not bendin it 2 suit our means![/quote]

Bending what? There is nothing originally there for us to bend.  It's a new idea without any previous rules.  If there was an original rule which was clear, then you could bend it.  But there is no rule on this and it is not clear.  So we can work within the boundaries of ijtihad and as long as there is no harm, then there is nothing haram in it.

[quote]Also!
"There is no proof that a woman CANNOT lead a prayer."
Then could u plz tll me where it does say a woman CAN lead the pray n not twist it 2 can or cant argumnt!
JAZAKALLAH KAHIR[/quote]

OK, here is what we have:
- The prophet used to lead prayers.
- If he wasn't there, and after he died, he said that Omar Ibn Il Khattab should lead the prayers.

Now, all that we can derive here is the following: 
1) if the prophet is here, he should lead the prayer
2) If the prophet isn't here, the most knowledgable man, or the best Muslim within us, should lead the prayer.

There is no reference to gender preferance.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview