Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote][font=Verdana][size=1][quote]Asalaam Alaikum.
... If it were women behind the men inclduing Ms.Wadud then from what I've read in the hadiths, it would've been fine. ...
... however, from my understanding it could either be two things:
one is that the people who went along to pray Jummah with her encouraged this prohibited act
 and 
the other could be that Muslims should've joined and should have raised their voice in order to stop this even from happening. Sadly, this did not happen and this meant that the Ummah had failed to stop a great sin from occuring. ...
May Allah (SWT) save us all from misguidance, Ya Rabbal 'Aalameen!
Fi'Amanillah[/quote][/size=1][/font=Verdana]
Wa Alaikum us Salaam Dear Sweet 16
I want to mention some things here mainly for you in this Regard:

•	Yes it is true that "Prayer lead by a Lady" is something that does not FALLS in the Category of HARAAM. At the moment I’m intentionally neglecting its reasoning right now.
•	So the People Offered their Jummah Prayer THERE didn’t do any PROHIBITED act.
•	& SORRY I personally can’t agree with your THIS derivation that “Ummah had failed to stop a great sin from occurring” Bcoz No.1) The Act wasn’t a SIN in itself though I agree that it HAD HAPPENED in a SINFUL WAY.& No.2) whole UMMAH had NOT failed, only YOU people; Muslim Residents of NY failed. YOU SEE, yesterday Religious Activists of My City; Gujranwala STOPPED a MIXED MARATHON. (Plz c pak news 4 details)
May Allah (SWT) save us all from misguidance, Ya Rabbal 'Aalameen![/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview