Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]QUOTE (sksamsherali): - Hadith believing Muslims make big claims on the so called scientific compilation of Hadith. Let it be clear however, that no matter how scientific you are in your compilation of what is "false" to start with, the compilation cannot make it true.

I think that Hadith might not be said or compiled primarily on the scientific basis but if we see today, their wisdom and truthfulness they are quite compatible with the latest scientific facts.

I shall quote a typical example of Hadith (Muslim- Book 33, No. 6392) about the creation of man in the womb with special reference to 40 days and it is found same today in the latest medical literature by the nonmuslim authors. Although brief steps of creation of man in the womb are mentioned in many Quranic verses but as far as my knowledge is concerned 40 days are not mentioned anywhere in Quran. 1426 year ago, who had told Mohammad (peace be upon him) about this matter?

I can comment only on about which I have the knowledge. Tell ANY Hadith, related to the human body from the head to toes, which you have found incompatible with the scientific facts. I will let you know very much implicitly how you are wrong.

QUOTE (Zulfee): - Suppose I (Zulfee) am the chief executive of some institution. My subordinates are bound to obey me as the chief executive only and never as Zulfee to obey me what I personally command them to do every other task everywhere. It is very simple.

The example is NOT suitable here. The chief executive and the subordinates have their entirely different job descriptions or the chief executive never does which the subordinates do BUT the Prophet Mohammad (peace be upon him) himself did the all as well, which he delivered to us to do.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview