Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]AA
QUOTE: - >>> How could you conclude that prophet Muhammad told this hadis? Imam Muslim born more or less than 200 years after the death of prophet Muhammad and he collected hadith from various sources more than 215-230 years after the death of Prophet, then how could you say with certainty that those who had told the hadith to him were truthful?

I have mentioned as read the Hadith otherwise I do not know about his work but can only comment on the basis of the common sense. If you say more or less 200 years after the death of the Prophet (peace be upon him), I give you an example. Suppose the period between someone’s date of birth and that of the grandfather of one’s father is more or less 200 years then although many decades passed the gap in the generation does not seems to be too much i.e. between someone and the grandfather of one’s father and this grandfather might be one of the companions of the Prophet Mohammad (peace be upon him). I mean to say that the maximum information transferred from his grandfather or the grandfather of his father and similarly the grandfathers of other people, may be right Or I mean to say there is not much gap of the generations.

QUOTE: - 2ndly, where in this hadis it is said that man is created after 40 days’?

I found from the post by oosman dated Saturday, April 23, 2005 at the following link:

http://www.studying-islam.org/forum/topic.aspx?topicid=1405&lang=&forumid=1

QUOTE: - Embryo, as an evolving biological organism, is not considered as a person. After a certain point in fetal stage soul (personality) emerges. When is the time of that crucial point?

According to the human Embryology, the EMBRYO is the stage BETWEEN FOURTH AND EIGHTH (between 28 and 56 days) weeks of pregnancy.

It is usually around fifth week when heart is developed and starts beating to show the SIGNS OF LIFE.  AFTER EIGHTS WEEKS till delivery it is called the FOETUS.

It must be remembered that in THE EMBRYONIC PERIOD (between 28 and 56 days) the different organs are developed while in THE FOETAL PERIOD the organs only grow in size till delivery.

How can you interpret the period between 28 and 56 days and around the fifth week of pregnancy when heart is developed and starts beating to show the signs of life? Is there any relation to 40 or as you said 50 days?

QUOTE: - >>> Actually, Mr Zulfee wants to say that his subordinates are bound to obey him as Chief Executive not as Mr Zulfee as we are bound to obey Muhammad as Messenger (Rasul) not as a person Muhammad (Personal command of Muhammad).

You are looking only the merits not the demerits of this example. Does any merit supersede the demerits?[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview