Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]You said >>> Don’t, you pls now mix singing with music. They are two separate things. Only music is Hara’m and not singing without music.

Actually you are the one who first mixed singing/music, drinking wine with glorification of Allah (swt). You are the one who declared all kinds of music haram, even that which glorifies Allah. I have been trying to explain to you that mucis that glorifies Allah cannot be haram, but you are stubborn.

You said >>> The person Oosman from USA (as shown only) has become mad just for his personal benefits.

>>> If he get less money of singing without music, may be helped as a miskeen about which Noble Quran commands us to help. I hope the muslims community will help him the needy.

Answer: There is no personal benefit for me, I am not a singer, nor do I like to listen to music or singing. To me it is a waste of time. But it is not haram to waste your time - that is my point. You should stop calling something haram which is allowed, because it is a big sin to call something haram that is not! If someone wants to waste their time, Allah has allowed it, it is not haram. It is of no benefit indeed, but it is not haram.

>>> Music is haram.

Where does the holy Quran say music is haram? YOu have not produced one verse where Allah said that! Why did Allah never use the word 'music' in any verse to say it is haram? Was it not easy for Allah to tell us music is haram? He never did that! So stop putting your own words in Allah's commands!

>>> It is better for anyone to leave Islam (if muslim) rather than to try making it impure and impose h

Exactly true, that is why you should stop polluting Islam with your false beliefs and stick to what Allah said.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview