Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Quote-Answer this, do you think Robin-hood philosophy of stealing from the rich to give to the oppressed is ok in Islam? Because that is exactly what these fundamentalist clerics believe in - to retaliate with random killings on the weak and defenseless civilians of other countries. Why don't they attack the enemy's military, why do they go for the defenseless people? Does Islam justify this?

>>>No it’s not to the best of my understanding. But this philosophy does not apply to the people who are involved in killings of civilians. They killing civilians because others killing their civilians. Why they don’t attack enemy’s military because they don’t have enough power to fight with them but in their home land they also fight with the occupied military and invading military. Their point of views what I understand so far is that the civilians of these countries are fully responsible of their Govts. actions.

Quote-Do you not realize we can never be successful if our tactics are unjust. Just because they kill our civilians, we cannot be justified in doing the same thing to their civilians.

>>>I 2nd your opinion. But if this situation I ever face, I am not sure now that what I will do that time.

Qoute: -Ends do not justify means, both ends and means should be justified and in accordance with Allah's laws. Those clerics and fundamentalists who twist and distort Allah's laws, may Allah curse them. Please stop supporting these people!

>>>I never support them; I condemn their action for motivating peoples to any thing, which against the Allah’s laws. But I always feel pain for those Muslim brothers in Kashmir, Palestine, Chechnya, Bosnia and where ever Muslims brutally murdered and those who are still alive but their life have become so miserable. I am very shame full to them that I never did any practical effort to minimize their suffering.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview