Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote][size=2]Salam brother,
Quote:-	Before I give you the Answer of your Question, you should Note that According to Us there are TWO equal sources of Isalm; Quran & Sunnah.
>>> Brother, may be it is according to you & your team but not according to us. However, could you please tell me which hadith should we believe? Is it Almighty Allah’s or hadith of people like you? Please see;
[6:114]   SHALL I SEEK OTHER THAN GOD AS A SOURCE OF LAW, when He has revealed to you THIS BOOK (i.e.Qur’an) fully detailed? Those who received the scripture recognize that it has been revealed from your Lord, truthfully. You shall not harbor any doubt. 
[18:27]   You shall recite what is revealed to you of your Lord's scripture. Nothing shall abrogate His words, AND YOU SHALL NOT FIND ANY OTHER SOURCE BESIDE IT.

Do you know what does mean to say OTHER THAN GOD AS A SOURCE OF LAW or YOU SHALL NOT FIND ANY OTHER SOURCE BESIDE IT(i.e. Qur’an)? Although I discussed regarding this matter several times in this forum. No need here to further discuss on the same point.
Quote:- BUT plz very Carefully NOTE that what is SUNNAH? 
>>> What is sunnah, brother? Do you believe that Almighty Allah said  His Prophet to do one thing and Prophet had done reverse? 
[17:110]  " ……………….You shall not utter your Contact Prayers (Salat) too loudly, nor secretly; use a moderate tone”.
Do you think that prophet heard the above commandment of Allah very carefully and then done the job according his own whims(not according to the above commandment)?

You can think this but not mine.

Moreover, Has there any mention of Prophet’s Sunnah in the Nobel Qur’an? If yes, then please show me only one reference from the Qur’an.
Quote:- It is the Practical Part of Islam & It is Very well Known Since Prophet Ibrahim (pbuh).
>>> Waoooo… you said it is the practical part of Islam yet we can’t find this (your so called practical part of Islam i.e. men-made sunnah) in the Qur’an, what a blaspheme!!!! Brother, we can find TRUE ISLAM ONLY IN THE NOBEL QUR’AN not in any other book.
Quote:- It has Reached us with the SAME "Twatur & Ijmaa" of Muslim Ummah as The Quran has. 
>>> Wrong understanding brother. Revelation, which Prophet Muhammed received, had already written by him or by the revelation writers during his lifetime. But hadith(because men-made sunnah can only be found in the men-made hadith book), which we posses, had not written by the Prophet Muhammad during his lifetime. Hadith were written first long long after his death & Prophet Muhammad was innocent about these (men-made hadith & sunnah). Moreover, Almighty Allah does not permit us to take another book/source besides Qur’an as religious source of Islam.
Quote:- Nevertheless STILL Quran has mentioned many of them in it & has given some instructions about them. 
>>>> Where brother, could you please show me any one instruction in the Nobel Qur’an?
Quote:- There are Many things of the Religion that Fall in this Category & Salat is One of them.
>>>> Please tell me where Qur’an says so.
Quote:- [If you are Interested in the Details of SUNNAH then plz Join our SHORT Course "Understanding the Sunnah"]
>>> First you please show me where did you find men-made Sunnah which is another source of Islam beside Qur’an. We don’t require to understand the men-made Sunnah which is adverse to the Qur’an. We require to understand the Islam from the Qur’an brother.
Quote:- In the Sunnah of Salat this Tradition has been Established That the Zuhar & Asar Prayers will be Offered with maintaining silence While other THREE will be Offered with maintaining moderate tone in First parts and with silence in 2nd parts.
>>> Who established these rules, some long bearded simple minded men? we should not believe them.
[9:31]   THEY HAVE SET UP THEIR RELIGIOUS LEADERS AND SCHOLARS AS LORDS, INSTEAD OF GOD. Others deified the Messiah, son of Mary. THEY WERE ALL COMMANDED TO WORSHIP ONLY ONE GOD.  THERE IS NO GOD EXCEPT HE. Be He glorified, high above having any partners. 
Do you get the message of the above verse? I don’t want to take them(religious leaders and scholars) as my lords. My Lord is only one God.
I hope this will sufficient for your, if not then you do as you wish.

Salam,
Samsher Ali[/size=2]

Edited by: ibrahim on Wednesday, December 07, 2005 8:20 AM[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview