Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote][size=2][quote]Neither speak thy Prayer aloud, nor speak it in a low tone, but seek a middle course between(17:110)

Ibne Abbas said that in Makkah Prophet (pbuh) and Sahabas used to recite verses loudly during Salat. Kuffar-e-Makkah used to makes noises and some times used bad language. So the order came from Allah that don’t recite too loudly so the Kuffar-e-Makkah gathered there nor too slow that own companions cannot heard it. This instruction was only for that particular situation. When the situation changed in Madina so this order was no more required.If Muslims ever faces the situation like Makkah, so they should follow the same order.
(Tafheem-ul-Quran) by Molana Maudoodi
For urdu please visit the folloing link.

http://www.tafheemulquran.org/Tafhim_u/017/surah_all.htm[/quote][/size=2]
[size=2]Salam,

People of this forum can easily see/realize what a ridiculous hadis, my brother Usmani, has mentioned above!! Yet he claimed himself that he is a Muslim!!! Whatever may be, I do not want say anything about his claim. I want to say here some words about his mentioned hadis. Please see;

Almighty Allah says in verse 17:110 that we should speak/utter our salat(every salat) in moderate tone. Nowhere He says that we should do this in particular situation. So how could you say that this instruction was only for the particular situation? Is Almighty Allah says so?
2ndly, Where it is said in the Nobel Qur’an that when the Muslims will not face the situation like Makkah, they should speak/utter their salat in different tones as you speak/utter now?
3rdly, if you think that situation is the main consideration point/matter, then why you utter/speak now your daily Fajr Salat(Morning prayer) maintaining in moderate tone? First two unit of Maghrib salat(evening prayer) maintaining in moderate tone and last unit of that salat in maintaining total silence? Same for Esha Salat(Night prayer). You speak/utter First two unit of Esha salat maintaining in moderate tone and last two unit of that salat maintaining in total silence? Why?
4thly, You said “When the situation changed in Madina so this order was no more required”
Is it mentioned in the Qur’an? What an audacity!!! May Allah forgive me. 
You blamed Almighty Allah and his Prophet knowingly!!! 
[68:37]   Do you have another book to uphold? 
[68:38]   In it, do you find anything you want? 
[68:40]   Ask them, "Who guarantees this for you?" 
[68:41]   Do they have idols? Let their idols help them, if they are truthful. 
[6:148]   The idol worshipers say, "Had GOD willed, we would not practice idolatry, nor would our parents, nor would we prohibit anything." Thus did those before them disbelieve, until they incurred our retribution. Say, "DO YOU HAVE ANY PROVEN KNOWLEDGE THAT YOU CAN SHOW US? YOU FOLLOW NOTHING BUT CONJECTURE; YOU ONLY GUESS." 
If one speaks/utters ones daily salat by maintaining in moderate tone then please tell me will it be right  or wrong according to your logic?
[42:21]   THEY FOLLOW IDOLS WHO DECREE FOR THEM RELIGIOUS LAWS NEVER AUTHORIZED BY GOD. If it were not for the predetermined decision, they would have been judged immediately. Indeed, the transgressors have incurred a painful retribution.

Salam
Samsher.[/size=2]

Edited by: ibrahim on Thursday, December 08, 2005 7:09 AM[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview