Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Dear Brother Samsher

[size=2]Quote:- Where brother Almighty Allah reminded to Prophet to perform FIVE REGULAR PRAYERs in their specific timings in the verse 17:78 or anywhere in the Qur’an?[/size=2]

Well for you I can Delete my Word of FIVE, so read it as "Regular Prayers". r u happy NOW?

[size=2]Quote:-  The next verse 17:79 says about MEDITATION not Salat-Al-Tahajjud. Please read 17:79;
" During the night, you shall MEDITATE for extra credit, that your Lord may raise you to an honorable rank. "[/size=2]

Well ur Translation is NOT acceptable on Language BASIS. "Tahajjud" is well known for the prayer that one offers when he Awake from Sleeping. & Arabic words r "FaTahajjad BiHi" i e with Quran Not "in Quran". Suppose we take it Meditation (which is Totally wrong) then it Can be in Quran NOT with Quran.

[size=2]Quote:-  Verse 17:110 says about the salat as a whole. This verse says we should read our salat (i.e. all salat) in moderate tone. Pl. see;

[17:110]   " YOU SHALL NOT UTTER [red]YOUR[/red] PRAYERS (SALAT) TOO LOUDLY, nor secretly; use a moderate tone. [/size=2]

Plz Think upon the words "YOUR" in the Verse. it's addressing Prophet Only not US.
 
[size=2]Quote:-  Almighty Allah says that Qur’an is fully detailed & fully detailed means fully detailed not as you think. Everything has been given in the Qur’an that are required for our GUIDANCE.[/size=2]

Yes u r Right BUT plz NOTE this TOO that Fully Detailed means here All those MINIMUM Details that Allah Himself wanted to Give the Human being for their Guidence and LOTs of things has been LEFT to them & they Can Get them By Using their GOD-Given Wisdom.

Plz Note this too that the word "ALL" in the Quran Does NOT each & every time mans ALL MAX POSSIBLE.

[size=2]Quote:-  you did not yet give any reference from the Qur’an in support of your own views that we should follow men-made hadith & sunnah besides Qur’an as religious source of Islam. All your tall-talk come to nothing if you can’t show any proof from the Qur’an in support of your opinion.[/size=2]

Well, 1st of All U shud at least Understand that to Me, at least, Men-Made Hadith & God-Given Sunnah are NOT same things & Hadith is NOT a Source of Islam & Can Never be whereas SUNNAH is.
In this Discussion I've Raised this points again & again & I've NOT YET got any Sufficient answer of that. MY point of View is, & WHOLE MUSLIM UMMAH beleives in it too, that The Quran; revealed to Muhammad (pbuh) 1426 yrs Ago has Reached us thru the "TWATUR & IJMAA" of THIS Ummah & the God-Given SUNNAH; Practical Portion of Islam has Reached us Exactly the SAME way, so there is NO reason to Differ in them. I've asked U people again & again that 1st tell us WHAT u SAY about HOW this Quran has Reached to U people??? It's NOT Enough for a BOOK to be taken as God-Given JUST Bcoz that we have found WRITTEN in that Book that it's a WORD of God. & I hope U people Do NOT Receive this Quran from God DIRECTLY & It's NOT revealed Today to Mr. Rashd Khalifah OR to someone ELSE.

Quote:-  The Qur’an is received from God and not from the Ijma…..

Yes That's WHAT I'm begging to Know that HOW U've Received Quran FROm God??? If NOT from the Ijma & Twatur & What's the PROOF w YOU that this Quran is God-Given???

Quote:-  The Almighty Allah gave us only Qur’an.

please show ANY Historical Proof that "The Almighty Allah gave us only Qur’an." Bcoz Claims From Quran cannot be accepted Unless & Untill one Claims that this Quran Is Being Revealed till NOW. It's Simple that If there is an ARGUMENT about a Scripture then the PROOF will Come from OUTSIDE.

Quote:- To know this you should/must read Mathematical Miracle of the Qur’an along with 74: 19-35.

Brother U or Anyone Else Can NEVER prove to me ur "Mathematical Miracle of the Qur’an " From 74:30. Bcoz It's More than a FOOLISH thing to do so From the Above Mentioned Verse. This verse can NO WAY be Related to Anything OTHER than the 19 Angels who r the Guardians & Keepers of Hell.

regards[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview