Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Assalam Alaykum,
Thanks for the reply. 
Brother You said:
[red]“You are misunderstood again brother. I told you that “you don’t require to know Code-19 theory to be a believer”, but that does not mean that you should reject this!!! If I say that ‘I don’t know this’ does that mean that ‘ I should reject this’? Strange!!!"[/red]
Actually I meant that according to this statement I do not need to know code-19 theory to be believer. If its not needed then this means BELIEVING IN Code-19 theory is not required to be believer and practice the religion completely. 
So if I do not believe in Code-19 theory then according to submitter's concepts i will not be able to extract the information about islamic rituals using Quran only. Like the number of rakah in prayers as RK has done. (www.submission.org) using Quran + CODE19 THEORY. So where will i get this information then? I will get it from the tawatur. RK also believes in method of Tawatur. This become another source of religon and your argument that Quran is only needed to PRACTICE religion completely becomes false. 
And if you say that by rejecting Code-19 theory you can not completely follow religion then again your claim that only Quran is needed to  PRACTICE religion holds false. 
And the one you follow himself uses:
1) Tawatur
2) Code-19 theory
along with Quran to follow religion.
I on the other hand base my religion on the following:
1)Quran
2) Sunnah transferred through Tawatur.
For me Ahadith does not add to the religion (thanks for Studying-Islam team for making me understand this). It is not primary nor secondary SOURCE for the corpus of Islam to be complete. (May be I should not have said its not primary source in my previous post). 
It just provides me with valuable information about Prophet and his best practices. AND Prophet Muhammad DID NOT make mistakes in his duty as a prophet, like RK has done in extracting practices from religion. 
So the summary is :
1)	If code-19 theory is irrelevant then by following Quran only you can not extract complete set of religious practices. 
2)	If code-19 theory is needed to extract religious practices from Quran then your claim that only Quran is needed to follow religious practices holds false. Check the pages of submission.org. And code-19 theory is used every where in this regard.
And you did not answer the following. And in this post again you have mentioned that RK made many mistakes. I asked:
“And you follow RK even when you accept his errors and at the same time you reject and label all the ahadith as wrong because you find errors in few of them”

BTW it is very easy to find faults in even the code-19 theory itself. 
How will you answer the following:
Pasted from:
http://www.understanding-islam.com/related/text.asp?type=question&qid=2059
[green]During the research and study done by Dr. Rashad Khalifa of the mathematical structure of the Quran he had to change "two", 2,  words in the latest edition of the Quran that broke the code of the "19 based"  mathematical miracle of the Quran. Omar E. Sherif and Mohamed A. Elhennawy, Submitters Group Detroit, Michigan 5/29/2002
The clearest evidence of this manipulation is Rashad Khalifa's translation of the Qur'an published in 1981 and a revised translation published in 1989. Although he claimed that Surah Al-Tawbah 9: 128 - 129 were insertions by later scholars he kept them in his translation published in 1981.  The word "Allah" is contained in verse 129 (in the 1981 translation):
If they turn away, then say: "God suffices me; there is no god except He; I trust in Him; and He is the Lord of the great dominion" (Rashad Khalifa's Translation, 1981, Al-Tawbah 9: 129)
His count of the word "Allah" (rendered "God" by him) in the entire Qur'an totaled 2698 = 19 x 142 in his 1981 published translation of the Qur'an. In his later translation published in 1989 he eliminates verses 128 - 129 of Surah Al-Tawbah yet he maintains that the total number of the word "Allah" is still 2698.  Even the number of verses is affected by this inconsistency, as it is no longer divisible by 19.  This is obviously a fallacy.  [/green][/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview