Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Brother Oosman,

Quote: -Does it makes sense to implement part of sharia that we like and part of it that we don't like? You agree with me that the Quran clearly says to flog him 80 stripes and reject his testimony. So we flog him, but since we like what he says, we accept his hadith! What hypocrisy is this?

Reply: -You and me can not interpret the Quran perfectly. See what I understood from this ruling of Quran that Allah wants to make the things so difficult that peoples don’t make play and think twice before involving in it. The evidence shows that Abu Bakra(ra) were not lying. He was the Governor of Bursa that time.

The person was accused was famous in the involvement with the women. He has carried out more than 100 marriages but at one time he don’t keep more than four. The lady was involved in this incident was not his wife. His house was near to incident place and three of his companions were there with him at that time. Being the Governor he might felt that he must go for that, but the things goes against him.

If Bukhari have given place to his narration in his work so there must some good reasons for that. If his work were given the status of second to Quran so fosure he would be very careful in given any place to any hadith in his work.

Quote: - Please explain to me how accepting his testimony is not a clear violation of the Quran?

Reply: -Before this incident I think noting wrong with that but after that I am not sure.

Quote: - Why should we hold the word of Ibn-Kathir or Bukhari or anyone else over the word of Quran? From what I understand, the Quran comes first, and humans make mistakes.

Reply:-Allah says that your eyes, ears and heart would be questioned at the Day of Judgment so we should use them not be (Lakeer kay Faqeer).

I already have explained but to me yours chances of making mistake are more obvious than Ibn-Kathir and Bukhari unless you proved them wronged.Do you think that they were not aware of this verse?[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview