Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote][quote]Reply:-I gives you an example here. There is no order to keep beard in Quran.But we find this in the sayings of Prophet(pbuh) or in (Sunnah) to keep bear. But still the size of beard is not there in the Sunnah.Then we go for the third option since no information is available 1)in Quran and 2) in Sunnah regarding the size of beards. This we find in the 3)Sahabah.[/quote]

Beard and other hairs grows naturally on almost all men's faces.You don't have to cultivate your face to grow beard.There is no concept of keeping beard,keeping eyebrows,keeping hair of other body parts.. in shariah.That doesn't mean that one can shave off beard,eyebrows,etc.. in ordinary situations!!!What will one answer to God on the Day of Judgement about this act ? I didn't like beard on my face so I shaved it,etc..God will judge the person.

The sunnah is shaving or trimming the moustaches,pubic area,under armpits,head after umra and hajj as these are passed on by the consensus of the sahaba(ra)

[quote]Now I give you another example here. The world is changing rapidly. Organ transplantation is possible now and this going on for quite a long time. Now the direction for organ transplant is not there in 1) Quran 2)Sunnah 3)Action of Sahabah.Now only left the forth option 4) Qiyas.This would be carried out by Scholars of today. Islam is a religion forever. So Islam must be able to give the answer of today’s and tomorrow’s needs.[/quote]

I never said that Qiyas is not to be done.Quran and Sunnah are the guidance for all mankind till qiyamah.Qiyas is done with the help of Quran and Sunnah.That doesn't mean that Qiyas in itself is a source of shariah.

Qiyas is done by mujtahids and qiyas of a mujtahid is bounding upon those who accept it.Its not bounding upon all the muslims of all times like the shariah is.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview