Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Brother Oosman

Quote: -But the problem is the hadith literature contains some very conflicting accounts of his directives and how can we be sure something is what he really said

Reply: -Brother we are not qualified to interpret hadith correctly. Thats why some times its looks to us that hadith conflicting each others. This happened with me as well but when I had check it with any Alim to whom I know, I always been given the satisfactory clarification on that. If we have some illness, we never attempt to take Madison our own, we always look for doctor for it. This Hadith is also is not easy subject. If Deen is our priority, we have to find those people on regular basis who can explain things to us.We have to check our from heart that, are we coming to net for acquiring the knowledge? or just to do chit chat here.Any new information, which I use to got from here, I try to double-check with peoples to whom I have trust. In Internet we don’t know who is sitting on other side, we just simply can’t rely on it. Allah sees how serious we are in acquiring the knowledge of deen or any other matter, once He sees that we are serious, He always help us by guiding us to the right people and the right litrature. Have a look on the followings.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
that not every Muslim can be a scholar. Scholarship takes a lot of time, and for the ummah to function properly most people must have other employment: as accountants, soldiers, butchers, and so forth. As such, they cannot reasonably be expected to become great ulama as well, even if we suppose that all of them have the requisite intelligence. The Holy Quran itself states that less well informed believers should have recourse to qualified experts: So ask the people of remembrance, if you do not know (16:43). (According to the tafsir experts, the people of remembrance are the ulama.) And in another verse, the Muslims are enjoined to create and maintain a group of specialists who provide authoritative guidance for non-specialists: A band from each community should stay behind to gain instruction in religion and to warn the people when they return to them, so that they may take heed (9:122). Given the depth of scholarship needed to understand the revealed texts accurately, and the extreme warnings we have been given against distorting the Revelation, it is obvious that ordinary Muslims are duty bound to follow expert opinion, rather than rely on their own reasoning and limited knowledge.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Quote: - Another thing I would like to add, about the innovation in religion, not every innovation in religion is bad. For e.g. tarawih prayer is an innovation, doing the adhaan twice for juma prayer is innovation, the imam speaking on the podium for khutba is an innovation, and the list goes on. An innovation that enhances the beauty of the religion is not bad.

Rely: -According to Prophet(pbuh) sayings, follow my Sunnah and Sunnah of my rightly guided Caliph.Abu Bkr (RA), Umer (RA), Usman (RA), Ali (RA) are the rightly guided Caliphs of Prophet (pbuh). All the innovations you have mentioned belongs to these four Caliphs.Other than these four no one can introduce any innovation in the religion.

Allah Hafiz[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview