Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Quote:-I am personally a non-sectarian sayyad but belong to a traditionally Sunni family. But excuse me why get personal?

Sorry for that. You talk about sects, for giving a better reply I asked you.
 
Quote: -Salaat is even today offered, perhaps with more regularity and 'khasooh and khashooh', by some of the sects which are considered to be non-Muslim by the mainstream

Reply: -This is very difficult to judged that who is offering his prayer with Khusooh-o-Khuzooh.This is some thing comes more from the heart and only Allah can see it. Giving their proper time to every action of prayer is also come under Khusooh-o-Khuzooh as well.If a non Muslim offering salat so it won't give any benifit to him.

This what I found very wrong that the people like me and you knows very little about the religion and we always very quick to criticize on others especially on Mullas.Let say If some one studied upto inter level or A level and if he criticize on some one’s article on physics, who is Master on that by giving his stupid logics, how fair he will be? And do the others will give any importance to his criticism?

But as far as the knowledge of deen is concerned its seems that we have took it for granted. As far as these Mullahs are concerned their knowledge of religion is far more better than us. There is no question about it. Their concept of understanding could be wrong on some issues.

The fair way will be if we have any disagreement with them (Mullahs) in any issue, we must first do our own study on that particular issue and reply them with reasons,logics and with Quran and Hadith references. This might help them to change their concept on that. At least people like me and others will listen to that and will be benefited from it.

Quote:-In my view all groupings on the basis of any religion are divisions of humanity into sects. The groups which use the word 'namaz' for their prayer are Musims, Ahmadies, Shias, Zartusht, etc., etc.

Reply: -Like in the case of Ahmadies with the consensus of Ulima and Scholars, they have been declared non-Muslim. But I feel that your view on that is otherwise, if I am not wrong. If I am rightly said above, then what are your basis on that and do you think you are more knowledgeable than those great Ulima and Scholars?
 
 
Quote:-It is perhaps why the Mullah avoid the use of the Quranic term salat and use instead the pagan term 'namaz' for their prayer.

Brother it is just the Urdu translation of Salat.Nothing wrong with that. I am sure we people use Namaz more than Mullahs.Can’t you see any thing good in those Mullahs.One thing good I can see instantaneously that they don’t talk bed about people like us as we always talk bad about them.

There is link of Tafheem-ul-Quran by Molana Maudoodi Sahib of Suea Al-Maun.
Please forgive me if I heart you in my reply.

http://www.tafheemulquran.org/Tafhim_u/107/surah_all.htm

Allah Hafiz

Edited by: usmani790 on Saturday, April 29, 2006 7:47 AM[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview