Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Dear Tilawat

Quote:-I was waiting for your comments but have seen none so far. Today I read Tafheem about interpretation of Soora Maoon. Sorry to say it makes the confusion worse confounded. In fact, as I had said earlier I respected Moulana Moudoodi for his integrity of character but that does not mean that I follow him blindly. I do not consider him a 'mufakkir' as he thought and used his 'aqli istidal' circumscribed by a parameter of his fixed 'Aqeeda'.

His cofused interpretation of the Soora bears ample proof to it. It would perhaps be waste of time to discuss it.

Quote:- You have mentioned the name of Moulana Moudoodi Mrhoom and his Tafheem. I had a great respect for that man and as I lived near his home in Ichhra for a long time I had the good fortune of praying with him in Jamia Ashrafia and even once in Mansoora when I stood beside him. I read his Tafheem also. But for your information he was also not considered an ‘Ullama’ according to the so called ‘Jayyad Ullema’

Reply: -Looking at yours first quote it seams yours self also not considering Molana Maudoodi as ”Ullama” as you said Jayyad Ullema not considered him.

You said about Molana Maudoodi

Quote:- I do not consider him a 'mufakkir' as he thought and used his 'aqil istidal' circumscribed by a parameter of his fixed 'Aqeeda'.

Reply: - I think these comments of yours to me more fit to your own self rather than Molana Maudoodi Sahib.He was a great scholar of Islam not in only my eyes but in the eyes of all the Muslims of world who ever knows him.

Who ever will go against yours prefixed understanding of Islam, you would not liked him. These Mullahs are easy targets only.

Quote: - Excuse me if you think in sectarian terms then it is useless to argue with you as a sectarian mind is a closed one not open to any conviction.

Reply: - What about your self, are you mind is open? I recommend you the Tafseer of Molana Maudoodi thinking that these Jayyed ulamas tafsser you might not accept and for you (Molana Maudoodi) as  you said you have great respect? All the respect gone when his tafseer goes against yours prefixed understanding of Islam.

Brother you don’t like Jayyaed Ulema, Mollahs, now even Molana Maudoodi.I told already any one disliking have no valve, until he is not providing any material with his disagreement with others. You are only using your Aqil.Go back and check the tafseer of Sura- Maun once again, Molana Maudoodi Sahib have provided so many references of Prophet (pbuh) Many sahaba like Ibne-Abbas (RA) Ali (RA) and others in his tafseer of Sura-e- Maun.He did not used his Aqal as you doing.The facts are other way wrong brother.

You Said: - His confused interpretation of the Soora bears ample proof to it. It would perhaps be waste of time to discuss it.

Now you can see that not only Molana Maudoodi confused you but also…I am afraid to write so Big names here.

Brother we are human; surly we can do mistakes. I could also be wrong in my opinions.If we are sincere in learning so one has give due respect to them. My intention is here to bring your mistake (as I felt) and made you realized.Others will not lost any thing also I pray to Allah for guidance. He also guides us with help of another brother. What I felt I have conveyed to you. You are well come to guide me so this is the way forward.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview