Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Salams,

Your opinions about allowing abortions before the soul joins the body are incorrect and you are completely mistaken in permitting the termination of a sacred human life which Allah has created.

According to that same hadith, it is Allah swt who decides the fate of the child, whether he or she will have a long life or what illnesses and disability that Allah will test him/her with.

You are misreading the prophet's hadith when you know the full implication in Arabic text.

Under no circumstances has the prophet ever given anyone the license to allow abortion of (unborn) babies or the murder of any child - period!

Life starts at conception as the Quran states that Allah created man from a drop of mingled fluid. Scientifically and Islamically the formation of a human being does not start only when the soul joins the body and the related hadith is not a license to give you free will to attempt to destroy life that Allah swt has created. The prophet pbuh NEVER ever stated that was the malicious reason of his hadith, otherwise according to your same illogical analogy then anyone can murder a sleeping human being because yet again the soul is not present in the body and get away with murder.

The killing of children, whether they are born or unborn is explicitly forbidden in the Quran in more than one instance. Must I remind you the verses even though you call yourselves scholars?

Don't forget, the punishment for abortion is clearly murder in the hadiths, for which the mother has to pay blood money for every morsel of flesh and bone for the child. And you will attain the sin for any reader who embarks on this path to sin.

In fact in Islam, a woman who dies during child birth is considered a martyr escapes your reasoning!

I am very disgusted to find that Muslim scholars are treating human life that was always known as sacred in Islam as a piece of burden or dirt to be rid of. Even the non Muslims care for their sick, their disabled and blind far better than us. We should be ashamed for our weakness of thought and lack of Islamic perception in such important and grave matters.

Edited by: thameena on Saturday, May 16, 2009 3:59 AM

hv edited the title T; &quot;aborton is Haram&quot; to &quot; is abortion haram?&quot; in order to leave a room for discussion:)[green]salam~[/green]

Edited by: hkhan on Friday, June 12, 2009 8:56 AM[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview