Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Quote-It is really very simple, if you can prove beyond reason of any doubt that what you have quoted are indeed the words of the prophet, and you are willing to go to hell if you are wrong

Brother there are two Ahadith quoted one from Bukhari and the other one is from Muslim.These both sources are commonly considered the most reliable sources.If you don’t want believe in these reliable sources, there many in this world to whom one even can’t prove that Islam is a true religion and Quran is the Book from Allah.

Brother I never said that you are layman and you don’t have good knowledge .What I mean was if some one don’t posses good knowledge, so he only do that what you have siad for these knowledgeable people.Here what you have said.

Quote:- It seems the opposite from these fatwas and hadith you have quoted. It seems these people want to lock up women and not allow them to go anywhere without men's permission - keep them backwards and un-educated, use for breeding purposes only.

Quote: Also if the majority of the people are jumping into the well, then why should I follow them? If majority of muslims belive in nonsense that is contradicting the holy Quran, then why should I believe in something that is inferior and contradictory to something that is superior and more holy?

Brother its not contradicting the Holy Quran, rather adding some thing to It.When Quran says “obey and follow the prophet”And if Prophet(pbuh) saying we find from reliable source,what is the problem then.

Quote:-The truth of the matter is, the holy Qur'an never says that women should stay indoors or they cannot go outside without a mahram. This is all man made stuff, using stories possibly falsely attributed to the prophet. If you are right, then bring the sanad of your hadith. And we can scruitinize the isnad and the characters of those who related these hadith. Otherwise this is all bs.

We all pray five times a day without any hesitation, while there is no order in Quran to pray five times a day.How many of us have seen the sanad of that hadith which says so.Any way you always can do your research on that.

This my brotherly advised to you don’t talk like that regarding any hadith even after you established from your finding that the hadith is not reliable.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview