Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]I don't know what to say...
The fact is that Allah tells you in the Holy Qur'an to ask the knowledgeable people if you don't possess any knowledge on a certain issue.
Quote:
...don't care  abt 'majority of scholars really bcoz that's not the criteria.

Excuse me sister, but if I don't rely on [b]my[/b] opinion or judgment on a certain matter, then I think that [b]is[/b] the criterion.

Quote:
I fail to understand that where did we gather this idea of shutting down our own brains in the ‘khichri’ of majority/minority of scholars.

But what if someone himself is involved in a "khichri" of [b]confused judgment[/b]? Shouldn't he consult a scholar, dear sister?

Quote:
Why did God give us brains then?

To choose between right and wrong, my dear; not to figure out solutions to problems we possess little knowledge about. If we were to judge matters ourselvs, we would be following our own whims and desires.

Quote:
...the criteria is what is most close to common sense in the light of the given facts; and if we keep our god conciousness and awareness of Qur'an and the taught ways of the prophet sws updated, we must believe that Allah would not let us go astray--insh'Allah

Now that's the only sentence in your post that I fully agree with. But then again, I think it'll be much better if I consult a scholar, for a scholar is an inheritor of knowledge from the Holy Prophet (SAW) himself; so he would know better.

Wassalaam, and Allah knows best.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview