Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote][purple] (aray K aap say kis ney kaha i'm/or all moderators at SI are religious scholars... [8)] [8D] if you need a scholarly reply plz write to query@studying-islam.org  ) [/purple]

[orange]'daraba' could be interpreted as actually 'gently beating' in some areas of the world even today-where it is a norm to do so-however one is not bound by this interpretation in other parts of the world where it demands punishment if one is accused of beating his wife or child. this is the beauty of islam in all times and ages as well as various cultures.[/orange]

[blue]however I have given my opinion based on solid evidence and understanding from Qur'an and the teachings of the prophet sws alongwith the examples of some other verses where you do not take the literal meaning for an order and use the evidence from the time 'n environment when the verse was revealed , other relevant verses as well as the practices carried fwd from the prophets (pbu them)-as learnt from the basic rules of language(interpretation of Qur'an, Language of Qur'an/zuban kay asool  from javed sb's 'meezan' you must be aware of- as you mentioned your affiliation with almawrid's studies) from my renowned and distant teachers- javed G sb and shehzad saleem sb(patron 'n CEO SI respectively)-  i am therefore satisfied with my opinion.

another example- we know about the rules of parda/hijab-and we understand on similar basis that even though Qur'an has used certain words and language like 'jilba'b' to describe that, yet we are not tied up in various parts of the world by one particular arab style of jilbab wore those days-but wherever we live we have to find a modest dress which covers us as per the teachings of modesty given by Islam.[/blue]

[green]however not necessarily everyone/ yourself feel similarly satisfied with the explanation given above; therefore if you still have objections and need a scholarly reply, you may write to query@studying-islam.org. plz note that moderators at SI are not the scholars of SI. but when needed they can direct you how to coordinate with the scholars;as mentioned above.[/green]

[orange]hope this helps [:)] [/orange][/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview