Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]AOA

That is fine you follow the line of which ever scholar you care to follow & i will follow the way I personally understand the Quran. I dont think much more can be said on that. 
 ]
However the line from Ghamdi you have quoted is rather logically not only weak but non existent. To justify violence against a wife by saying when all other options are exhausted as somehow excuses it. According to your scholars (as you dont appear to have a view and are expecting me to simply accept which ever scholar you follow) the bottom line is that Islam allows physical violence and that is morally acceptable to you purely your progative.

Where in the Quran do you find the mother son, teacher pupil relationship. To me you are simply adding to the religion simply to dilute something you morally find very uncomfortable but then that is up to you. I have given you my understanding which is reinforced by many others who have looked at the topic in depth.

As for you hitting a brick wall. You were already there you have not made the slightest effort to for a second to look beyond your long established acceptance of the scholars you choose to follow.

Anyway no more to be gained from this.

Next point you raised.

So why do you think Quran allows slaying of non believers? I have already given you the full quototion from the quran as to why I think your statement is a nonsense.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview