Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Assalamu Alaikum wa rahmatullah wa barakatuh.

Dear brother Aboosait.

please re check my post and quote I said to &quot;my knowledge&quot; I do not claim

to be knowledgeable, can YOU provide the evidence that the prophet s.a.w was NOT told of the incident, after all it has been passed down to us all these years later and the sahabah were closer to the prophet s.a.w. than we are.

brother Aboo for someone who is so fond of quoting i thought you would have got this one right
The words i used in my post if you look back were,

&quot;hiding behind a tree and throwing stones at her&quot;

This is a long way im sure you will agreefrom the word you used &quot;pelted&quot; with all respect brother i think you are gettin a little over excited in your description of this act.
And no a man does not have the right to adopt any means to make his wife obey and nowhere in my posts have i expressed or implied this opinion.
The prophet s.a.w says He is best who is best to his wife and i am best to my wife. The treatment of women is also mentioned in the last speech of the prophet s.a.w

Quran and Hadith go hand in hand brother but please remember that revelations came to the prophet s.a.w at various times according to conditions and occasions also when sometimes after the prophet s.a.w. was asked a question he s.a.w refered it to Allah subanalla wa taallah and gave his reply sometime later therefore you cannot just quote quran and hadith you have to be aware of when and why revelations came and what was the times and circumstances that led up to the prophet s.a.w issuing the orders and advice he did.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview