Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Assalam alaikum,

I couldn't help myself from exclaiming when you said >>> that men will get hoors and intimate relationships while women’s minds will be erased and will become the head of the hoors. <<<

Where do you get the idea that women's minds will be erased like that? Quran says no such thing nor does it say women will become hoors. From what I understand, hoor is a different creation of Allah taala. Every woman on earth, like every man, will have her recompense in paradise or hell. Hoor is something different from a woman, its a new creation.

You said >> To think how many men will wrongly view women and see them as just objects of desires, while the poor women have just got to accept their fate.<<<

Is it wrong that men desire women? Is that immoral or impure?

Quran 3.14: Beautified for men is the love of things they desire; women, ....

This is how Allah made men, first thing He mentions that men covet is women.

You said >>>What about non-Muslims who use this hoor issue to attack Islam<<<

There are from non-Muslim men who convert to Islam, one reason being the hoor reward and there being no such reward in the Christian philosphy. There is a reason why Allah mentions the hoor reward for men.
 We cannot re-interpret the Quran to appease people who wish to attack Islam, we will never be able to appease them.

You said>>>Are you trying to tell me that you believe that Allah Swt will grant men dirty desires, desires which have gone beyond the boundaries of decency and modesty?<<<

Let me quote this verse yet again:

"Gardens of Eden which they enter, underneath which rivers flow, wherein they have what they will." Quran 16.31

Does it not say that there is no limit to what you can have in Paradise? Isn't that very clear? Does it not say that whatever desire you have, it will be granted to you? Does it say only good desires will be granted and evil will not be granted? No.

The morals, good, bad - these concepts only hold true in this life. They have no meaning in the after life. In the after life, we would have been already judged and being rewarded or punished. The concept of good and evil only has some meaning when you know you will be judged for an action. Once you have already entered paradise or hell, you will not be judged for your actions there. It is over, that is the end. There is no longer a concept of good or evil or dirty desires any more. You cannot do good or evil in Hell or in Paradise. You just exist there and either you are in agony or in delight, depending on where you are.

That is my understanding and Allah knows best.[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview