Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Assalam o alaikum!

With due respect i wd say that brother Tariq has mentioned about the &quot;claim of prophethood&quot; by the persian descent.

Look at his reply to one of the counter questions:

&quot;We do not understand that this saying proves the veracity of the claim of any person of Persian descent that he is a prophet of God. If that is the case then any Persian man can put that claim in his favor. Besides this interpretation of the saying contradicts the Qur'an and the consensus of the Muslims Ummah on the fact that the Prophet Muhammad (sws) explicitly explained that he was the last of the Messengers of God. The issue of prophet hood is not a trivial matter. It does not depend on individual narratives. The Muslims belief in this regard is based on explicit Qur'anic assertions and their Prophet's clear statement which they have carried all the way down from him that no prophet is going to succeed him&quot;.

Brother Tariq is discussing the claim of prophethood. Important thing is that in question Mirza ghulam Ahmed is only called as a person among the Persians to bring faith back to earth. Has it been claimed in the question that the hadith mentions a prophet to come. it says only a person. So there was no question of prophethood in the said question, but answer given was refute of prphethood. Not only the refute of prophethood but also the claim of prophethood. That is why I ve requested brother Tariq hashmi and studying-islam.org to please prove the claim of Ghulam Ahmed.

Please once again check the answer and also the answer of the counter question. Link is given below.

http://studying-islam.org/querytext.aspx?id=308

i ve also mailed to query@studying-islam.org.

JzaakAllah

SZ[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview