Studying Islam

Post Reply

Username

Invalid Username or Password

Password

Format

Message Icon

Message

- Forum Code is ON
- HTML is OFF

Smilies

[quote]Assalam o alaikum!
Dear Umar baig! If u think that whole text of links gives the answer to my question then please give me that one particular statement in the all above links which gives the answer (as ur statement shows that u wd ve gone through whole text).

Now coming to the reply of mbellos

My problem is that i ve been searching the answer of this question since long. When i came across one of the answers to the question regarding Ghulam Ahmed by brother Tariq Hashmi, i thought that he will be knowing the answer. I asked him and he replied me via email. His reply is this:

[blue]&quot;assalaam o alaikumI am sorry for not being able to respond to your question earlier. I was busy in finalizing another assignment. I have not studied the writings and claims of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani directly. What I was trying to refute, therefore, is the position that Mirza Qadiani was a prophet regardless of the matter whether such a claim is validly ascribed to him or not. When we try to falsify trinity we do not negate teachings of the Prophet Jesus. Similarly when we try to refute the claim that Mirza Qadiani is not a prophet we negate such a claim regarding him. No matter who puts forward such a belief. It is well known that many people do in fact believe in his prophethood. Regards,Tariq Mahmood Hashmi&quot;.[/blue]

As far as reply from Brother Ibrahim is concerned i wd like to ask directly to Brother Ibrahim:

&quot;Brother Ibrahim Do u think that u have answered my query?&quot;

and lastly mbellos wrote
[blue]&quot;If you want to follow Mirza Ghulam Muhammad, Do it, and dont waste everyone elses time&quot;.[/blue]

I wd like to ask all the participants of the discussion (including mbellos) and the moderators that &quot;Is discussion of any topic, any question, any misconception is wastage of time&quot;?

Regards!

Edited by: salahuddinzafar on Wednesday, October 22, 2008 9:50 AM[/quote]

Mode

Check here to be notified by email whenever someone replies to your topic

Show Preview